Polenta and Mushrooms and Love Past

I never intended to fall in love with J. I told him so on our second dinner together. I had just returned to San Francisco after six years out of the country, nearly ten years away from my home city. It wasn’t a good time for me to get involved. I told him so.
Then he tried to kiss me—and, after demurring several times, I let him. And again, and again.
It was December, a mildly cold night, and we wandered the streets of Palo Alto looking into shop windows lit up for the holidays. Our bellies were full with the warmth of a meal just finished and a cold night in California is to be relished, they don’t come all that often. At one point, in the shadows between two buildings, I pulled J towards me and kissed him back, as if I meant it. It is not in my nature to do such a thing, but I dared myself to be someone else for the evening. Months later, J told me that was the moment when he first thought he might have a chance with me.
As the weeks passed I found myself falling for this man who played no games. He came to me with his heart in his hands, willing and wanting to entrust it to me. It was a change from the college relationships I had known before. J’s games were different—planning a future, shopping for furniture, talking about children. He told me what he wanted to engrave on our wedding bands. I hadn’t been looking for marriage but I liked what we were to each other, I liked the feeling between us. Playing the field no longer seemed appealing.
He brought me bagels from New York, his hometown, and was thrilled when I liked them. I introduced him to hikes on Mt. Tam and brunch at Howard's Cafe in Occidental. One day he took me down to Sunnyvale so I could taste the pizza he said was most like New York pizza. I was unimpressed but didn’t say so; I didn’t want to hurt his feelings. It wasn’t until I ate real New York pizza in Brooklyn two years later that I understood what he was talking about. Our Chinese food preferences matched perfectly, and one evening in the middle of that winter we found “our” restaurant.
I can’t remember how we stumbled on the little Italian place at the foot of Fillmore Street. The proprietress was named Maria and told us that she had run a restaurant in North Beach for years but wanted to downscale—she was a grandmother now, after all. This little hole in the wall was her retirement restaurant.
We were seated at the window table and no sooner had we placed our order than the waiter came with two steaming bowls of soup, a rich-smelling minestrone. J and I looked at each other.
“But we didn’t order soup.” We felt bad pointing this out, everyone seemed so nice.
“Maria thinks you need soup,” the waiter said with a smile, before retreating to the kitchen.
We did need this soup—rich and filled with vegetables, beans, noodles. We didn’t know how much we needed this soup. We spooned it up, grinning at each other. It was the best minestrone either of us had ever tasted—even J said so, and the New Yorker was picky about Italian food.
This is how we fell for the little Italian place around the corner from Chestnut Street. It wasn’t a neighborhood either of us lived near, but we made the pilgrimage often. Maria always greeted us warmly, always seated us in the window. It was our place.
This all came back to me recently when I saw a recipe for creamy polenta and wild mushrooms. This is the dish I ordered every time we ate at Maria’s. To me this small dish of polenta with Taleggio cheese and mushrooms was the perfect food. I could have eaten it every day for a month.
Months passed and J and I began to discover that, as much as we shared a tender heart, the lives we envisioned for ourselves were very different. He dreamed of moving back to New York, a place that would always be home to him. I had just come home to the West Coast, after a decade of being away, and I wasn’t eager to leave. He was willing to give up New York for me, he told me so, but I wasn’t sure that I wanted him to.
The truth is I wasn’t ready to get married, and secretly I was beginning to wonder if we were right for each other. It could have worked, certainly, but I was beginning to doubt that it should.
J was a city boy, and I yearned for the mountains and the coast and forests and woods. I had begun to dread the summer—would I have to choose between my love for this man and my love of the wilderness, the place I felt most alive? Such choices should not have to be made. When I tried to think of J amidst the high mountains and alpine lakes where I felt so at home, all I could imagine was his discomfort. Was ours a relationship that only worked in the off-season?
It may sound superficial—this issue of incompatible hobbies—but it represented something deeper. My adventurous and untraditional heart chafed against his more logical, conventional mind. The girl who had grown up on the wild cliffs of a rugged western coast was not a good match for the boy marked by the grid of New York City. When I asked him if he would ever consider taking a year off from work—to travel or live abroad—J looked at me like I was crazy. “I couldn’t just quit my job,” he said, mild panic in his voice. “What would I do?”
The last time we saw each other was October of that year. J had been in New York since June. We had seen each other a few times since then, had spoken on the phone, but our lives were moving in different directions. We both knew it.
We had dinner at Maria’s, the place that had always been our place. They seated us in the window and I ordered my polenta. We were gentle with each other that night, holding close what had been, but acknowledging that the possibility had passed. There was still love and admiration, would always be, but sometimes it is not enough.
“I was never adventurous enough for you,” J told me softly, ruefully. “I never wanted to raft the Amazon—and I know, given half a chance, you would.”
“I was too political for you,” I said. We had fought only twice in our relationship, both times over my fierce feminist and environmental beliefs. He laughed and shook his head but did not disagree.
We lingered that night, over polenta and wine and what might have been. We held each other tight for a moment, then we each went our own way in the dark.
Maria’s restaurant closed not long after that and I was secretly relieved. I could never have gone back, yet it would have pained me to know it continued without my presence. This meant that I’d never again taste her minestrone, but I hoped she was enjoying a real retirement with her grandchildren.
As for the polenta, I hadn’t considered recreating it until I found the recipe in a magazine. Here was Maria’s polenta, or near enough. Did I dare attempt it? They say you can never go home, perhaps one should not even try.
One recent grey day, I boiled my water and cooked my mushrooms and sat down to a meal I didn’t think I would ever taste again. The mushrooms melted into the creaminess of the polenta, the cheese was soft and dreamy warm. It is a tiny thing, this flavor combination, but sometimes small tastes can hold entire worlds within them—romances, possibilities, chapters written, choices made, windows that appear to be closed. One bite of this dish brought it all back: a decision made, a love left behind.
It was six years later when I next heard from J, but that is a story for another time.
For now the polenta is hot and needs to be eaten. We can never know what our future holds. Polenta or love, each needs to be savored in the moment. Who knows what tomorrow will bring? For now, the polenta is hot. Eat.
POLENTA WITH MUSHROOMS
One generous serving, or two appetizer-sized portions
One cup uncooked polenta (I prefer a coarsely ground polenta rather than the somewhat fluffy instant version, choose whichever suits you best)
One and a half cups wild or cultivated mushrooms, sliced into nice bite-sized bits
One teaspoon olive oil
1/4 to 1/2 cup Taleggio cheese, rind removed and cut into small strips
Salt and pepper to taste
Cook the polenta in salted water according to package instructions until soft.
Sauté mushrooms in olive oil until cooked fully through and soft. Add a generous pinch of salt as soon as the mushrooms are coated in oil and beginning to soften. Add more oil to prevent sticking, if needed.
Spoon the polenta in a bowl, top with thin strips of cheese. Spoon mushrooms over polenta. Add salt and pepper to taste.
Eat, sigh, enjoy.
NOTE: Taleggio, if you are not familiar with it, is a washed rind cheese from the Lombardy region of Italy. Though it is a somewhat stinky cheese, the flavor doesn’t match the smell—it is mild and buttery. The high fat content means it melts like a dream.


















